In 1984 the California Legislature authorized an emergency purchase of approximately 777 acres of land along the Upper Truckee River to save it from development, noting the land’s unique and irreplaceable resources and its extreme value to the maintenance of the water quality of Lake Tahoe. On the west side of the river, Washoe Meadows State Park was established in 1987 and the privately developed golf course was allowed to remain on the east side of the river and designated as a State Recreation Area.
Washoe Meadows provides affordable, year round, family-friendly recreation. Some of the centerpieces of the approximately 608 acre park are the usually diverse fens—wetlands ecosystems that host rare native plants and that filter water that flows to Lake Tahoe. The park’s forests are rich in native wildlife, including black bear, pine marten, foxes and migrating birds.
The UpperTruckeeRiver, home to many species of fish, forms the park’s eastern boundary. The river separates the state park from an 18-hole golf course that operates in a state-owned recreation area.
In 2000, the state released a proposed plan to restore the UpperTruckeeRiver through the golf course that sends sediment and chemical runoff into Lake Tahoe. Chemical runoff from the golf course was a concern as well as the golf course’s location on the banks of the river and in its floodplain.
The state’s preferred alternative was to reroute the river and move half the golf course into WashoeMeadowsState Park. To do so would require the state to downgrade protections afforded state parks. In 2011 the State Parks Commission voted to approve State Parks request to downgrade the status of WashoeMeadowsState Park to a state recreation area. This reclassification is unprecedented in California.
The Washoe Meadows Community, a nonprofit grassroots group was founded in 2006 to protect the natural, cultural and recreational resources of WashoeMeadowsState Park. The group is an alliance of other conservation groups and individuals who value open space and state parks.
Washoe Meadows Community seeks a collaborative approach to resolving the project issues. However, we filed a lawsuit in 2011 over the State Parks Commissioners decision to declassify a significant portion of WashoeMeadowsState Park, instead making it a State Recreation Area, which we believe sets a dangerous precedent for California’s park system.
Independent scientific review has shown serious deficiencies in river restoration plan. A major concern is that massive amounts of earth movement are involved instead of a process-based river restoration which would have minimal risk to infrastructure and ecology. Massive logging and construction of a golf course in Washoe Meadows would further destroy the natural resources, with the potential to increase sediment flowing into Lake Tahoe.
Massive excavation would require removing more than 1,600 trees, and allowing construction near the park’s fens and wetlands threatening the delicate hydrologic balance that allows the fens and wetlands to filter the water that flows to Lake Tahoe and provide an abundance of plants and wildlife.
Free, family-friendly outdoor recreation in a natural area would be replaced with a single use—a golf course.
The golf course development requires the downgraded reclassification of state parkland that sets a dangerous precedent for the future of California State Parks.
What We Support:
The Washoe Meadows Community supports the restoration of the UpperTruckeeRiver. Current best practices for river restoration call for a lighter human touch and reliance on natural processes. Such advanced restoration techniques would reduce sediment flowing into the lake while providing riparian habitat.
We also support preservation of WashoeMeadowsState Park. Scientists have determined that the park holds valuable and rare natural and cultural resources. Washoe Meadows provides affordable, year-round, dispersed recreation in a natural setting.
We strongly object to the proposed project, which ties the river’s restoration to the golf course expansion. Not only would the proposal devastate irreplaceable natural features of the park, it has required the unprecedented move by the Parks Commission to reclassify parkland in contravention of the 1987 legislative statute defining Washoe Meadows’ boundaries.
We support a more sustainable alternative offered in the proposal: Restoring the river and maintaining the integrity of WashoeMeadowsState Park.
We support El Dorado County Supervisor Norma Santiago’s alternative plan that would integrate WashoeMeadowsState Park and the adjacent Lake Valley State Recreation Area. The vision includes protecting the parks’ resources while developing an integrated economic and recreational plan providing varied, all-season activities for local and visiting users. We believe this proposal is consistent with the State Parks mission to preserve and protect California’s parks.
We need a Parks Department that cares about state park land and we need Natural Resources leaders who recognize WashoeMeadowsState Park as one of the jewels of the California State Parks system.
California Planning & Conservation League
California Sierra Club
Defense of Place
League to Save Lake Tahoe
Resource Renewal Institute
World Water and Climate Network
Tahoe Area Sierra Club